When buyers are shopping for a mortgage, it’s easy to focus on one thing: interest rate.
Who can blame them?
If one lender advertises a lower rate, lower fees, or promises to close faster than everyone else, it seems like an easy decision.
But after hundreds of real estate transactions, I’ve learned that a lender’s true value isn’t measured by the rate they advertise.
It’s measured by what happens when the transaction gets complicated.

Looking Beyond the Marketing
Recently, I worked on a transaction in which the buyer chose to finance through Tomo Mortgage after being attracted by many of the benefits promoted on the company’s website, including competitive rates, no lender fees, fast approvals, digital convenience, and quick closings.
Those are attractive promises, and I understand why many buyers would consider them.
However, every buyer should remember one important fact:
A mortgage isn’t just a financial product. It’s a service.
And the quality of that service can determine whether your transaction succeeds or fails.
A Real-World Example
The experience described below reflects one transaction that I personally worked on in San Diego. I can’t speak to every loan Tomo Mortgage handles or every customer’s experience. I can only share what occurred during this escrow.
The first indication that problems might arise actually occurred before escrow even opened.
When a listing agent receives multiple offers, it’s common practice to call each lender to verify financing, discuss the strength of the buyer’s qualifications, and gain confidence that the lender can successfully close the transaction.
These conversations happen every day in our industry and often influence whether a seller accepts one offer over another.
In this case, the listing agent struggled to reach the lender despite multiple attempts.
Phone calls were not returned.
Emails went unanswered.
Fortunately due my experience and communication and perhaps a bit of luck, the offer was still accepted.
Had the seller or listing agent decided to move onto another offer because they couldn’t establish confidence in the financing, my buyer could have lost the home before escrow even began.
Unfortunately, communication challenges continued with our lender throughout the transaction.
During the length of the transaction, emails, texts, and phone calls often went unanswered. It felt as though the loan was being relegated to the “I’ll get to it eventually pile” rather than a transaction involving real people who needed and deserved timely communication.
Important information was frequently not shared until deadlines were quickly approaching or had unfortunately already passed. Several underwriting documents that could have been easily obtained through simple communication with the agent, escrow, or title were not requested clearly or in a timely manner, creating unnecessary last-minute pressure to meet contingency deadlines.
As timelines tightened, it became increasingly difficult to get clear and accurate updates. With multiple contacts assigned to the loan, no one seemed able to provide straightforward answers about what was needed or where the loan stood. The lender’s repeated delays and failure to communicate transformed what should have been an exciting and celebratory milestone into an experience marked by frustration, uncertainty, and avoidable complications.
This lack of communication created doubt, stress, and unnecessary risk for everyone involved, ultimately putting the buyer’s purchase in jeopardy. As a result, we had to agree to pay the seller a per diem for each day beyond the original close of escrow date. This additional cost had the potential to offset any savings the buyer may have gained by choosing Tomo in the first place.
Could those issues have ultimately been avoided?
Most likely.
But that’s not really the point.
The point is that consistent communication and proactive problem-solving often prevent situations like this from becoming emergencies in the first place.
Why Communication Matters
A lender’s job is far more than collecting documents and issuing loan approvals.
A GREAT LENDER!!!!
- Manages expectations.
- Communicates frequently.
- Identifies potential problems early.
- Keeps everyone informed (this one is huge).
- And helps protect one of the largest financial investments most people will ever make.
When communication breaks down:
- Buyers become anxious.
- Sellers begin questioning whether the transaction will close.
- Listing agents lose confidence.
- Escrow is left waiting.
- Deadlines are missed.
And in competitive markets, those issues can easily cost someone their dream home.
Reputation Matters
Here’s something many buyers don’t realize.
Real estate professionals talk.
Listing agents remember which lenders consistently communicate, close on time, and solve problems.
They also remember lenders whose transactions have been difficult.
When a seller receives multiple offers that are otherwise very similar, the lender attached to the offer can absolutely become a deciding factor.
If a listing agent has previously experienced repeated communication problems or failed closings with a particular lender, they may advise their seller that another offer—even one with a slightly lower purchase price—presents less overall risk.
In other words, your lender’s reputation can influence whether your offer is accepted before negotiations even begin.
That’s not intended to punish buyers.
It’s simply a matter of helping sellers choose the offer that appears most likely to reach the closing table.

What a Great Lender Looks Like
This experience reinforced why I continue to recommend mortgage professionals like Mark Feder who is one of my preferred lenders; although, I have several others that I have also worked with and had great experiences with.

A great lender answers the phone.
Returns emails and text messages promptly.
Communicates honestly—even when the news isn’t perfect.
Explains complex financing in language buyers actually understand.
Alerts clients and agents to potential issues before they become emergencies.
And most importantly, provides the confidence needed to make important contractual decisions, including whether it is appropriate to remove loan contingencies.
Those qualities don’t always show up on a rate sheet. But they often determine whether a transaction closes smoothly or becomes unnecessarily stressful.
Final Thoughts
Everyone wants a competitive interest rate.
Everyone wants lower fees.
But the lowest advertised cost doesn’t always produce the lowest overall cost if delays, uncertainty, or financing issues place the transaction at risk.
When choosing a lender, ask yourself one question:
If something unexpected happens, who do I want standing beside me?
Because buying a home isn’t just about getting a loan.
It’s about successfully getting to the closing table.
Click the above link to see my Google Reviews and connect with me.
Kathleen Moen, Compass Real Estate
CALDRE: 02087478